Psychological injuries are not always as visible as physical injuries, but their impact can be just as significant.
A serious accident or traumatic event can affect a person’s mental health as well as causing physical injury. Some people may develop symptoms that resolve relatively quickly, while others can experience longer-term conditions that affect their work, relationships, sleep and everyday life.
Where a recognised psychiatric condition has been caused by the fault of another party, it may form part of a personal injury claim.
What Is a Psychiatric Injury?
In personal injury law, psychiatric injury generally means a medically recognised psychiatric condition.
Examples can include:
- Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)
- Depression
- Anxiety disorders
- Adjustment disorders
- Other recognised psychiatric conditions
Feeling upset, frightened or distressed following an accident is entirely understandable, but these reactions do not necessarily amount to a psychiatric injury for the purposes of a personal injury claim.
Medical evidence will usually be required to establish whether a recognised condition has developed and whether it was caused, or materially contributed to, by the incident in question.
Can You Make a Personal Injury Claim for Psychological Injuries?
Potentially, yes.
Psychiatric injury can arise in many of the same circumstances as physical injury, including:
- Road traffic accidents
- Accidents at work
- Accidents in public places
- Serious or traumatic incidents
A psychiatric injury may form part of a claim alongside physical injuries. For example, someone seriously injured in a road traffic accident may sustain physical injuries but also develop PTSD or anxiety as a result of what happened.
In some circumstances, a recognised psychiatric condition may be the principal injury even where the person has suffered little or no physical injury.
As with other personal injury claims, establishing that a psychiatric injury exists is only part of the picture. It must also be established that another party was legally responsible for the circumstances that caused it.
What Types of Psychiatric Injury Can Be Claimed?
Psychiatric injuries can affect people in very different ways.
Conditions encountered in personal injury claims can include PTSD, depression, anxiety disorders and adjustment disorders, but the precise diagnosis will depend on the individual circumstances and medical evidence.
Symptoms might include:
- Flashbacks or intrusive memories
- Anxiety or panic attacks
- Disturbed sleep
- Nightmares
- Low mood
- Difficulty concentrating
- Avoidance of particular places or activities
- Difficulties returning to work
- Changes in social or family life
The important issue is not simply the label attached to the symptoms, but whether a recognised psychiatric condition has developed and what impact it has had on the individual.
What Is the Difference Between a Primary and Secondary Victim?
The distinction between primary and secondary victims can become important in psychiatric injury claims.
Primary Victims
A primary victim is someone who was directly involved in the accident and was exposed to the risk of physical injury.
For example, someone involved in a serious road traffic collision may or may not have suffered physical injury but subsequently develops PTSD because of the experience.
Secondary Victims
A secondary victim is someone who was not personally endangered in the same way but develops a psychiatric illness after witnessing injury or danger to another person.
The rules governing secondary victim claims are considerably more restrictive.
The law may consider matters including:
- The relationship between the person claiming and the person injured or endangered
- How close the person was to the accident in time and location
- Whether the accident or its immediate aftermath was directly witnessed
- Whether a recognised psychiatric illness resulted
The distinction can be legally complex and will depend heavily on the particular circumstances.
Can I Claim Psychiatric Injury After Witnessing an Accident?
In some circumstances.
Claims involving people who witness injury to someone else are known as secondary victim claims and are subject to particular legal requirements.
The law restricts the circumstances in which these claims can be made. It is not enough simply to have learned about an accident or to have experienced understandable grief or distress afterwards.
The courts will consider factors such as the closeness of the relationship, the person’s proximity to the incident and whether the accident or its immediate aftermath was perceived directly.
The law in this area was considered by the UK Supreme Court in 2024 in Paul and another v Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust [2024] UKSC 1, which confirmed significant restrictions on secondary victim claims, particularly where the event witnessed was a later medical crisis rather than an accident.
The decision also considered the position under Scots law and confirmed that similar principles apply in Scotland.
Do I Need a Psychiatric Diagnosis?
Medical evidence is particularly important in psychiatric injury claims.
An appropriately qualified medical expert may be asked to assess the person and consider:
- Whether a recognised psychiatric condition is present
- The diagnosis
- The severity of the symptoms
- When the symptoms began
- Whether they were caused or worsened by the accident
- The effect on work and everyday life
- Treatment requirements
- The likely recovery period
- The longer-term prognosis
The expert’s role is important because personal injury compensation is not generally awarded simply for being upset or distressed by an event. The evidence must support the existence of a recognised psychiatric injury.
What Evidence Is Used in a Psychiatric Injury Claim?
Different forms of evidence may be relevant depending on the circumstances.
These can include:
- GP records
- Hospital records
- Counselling or psychological treatment records
- Psychiatric records
- Prescription records
- Independent medico-legal reports
- Occupational health records
- Evidence of absence from work
- Evidence of the impact on everyday activities
- Evidence of financial losses arising from the condition
It is important to tell a treating doctor about psychological symptoms rather than focusing only on physical injuries following an accident.
What if I Already Had Mental Health Difficulties?
A previous mental health condition does not necessarily prevent someone from making a personal injury claim.
The important question is what effect the accident had.
For example, an accident may cause a new psychiatric condition, aggravate an existing condition or cause previously controlled symptoms to return.
Medical records and expert evidence can help distinguish between a pre-existing condition and any additional impact caused by the accident.
As with physical injuries, the individual circumstances and medical history must be considered carefully.
What if I Have Physical and Psychological Injuries?
It is common for a serious accident to cause more than one type of injury.
Someone involved in a road traffic accident might, for example, suffer orthopaedic injuries alongside anxiety, depression or PTSD. The physical and psychological consequences of the accident should be considered together when assessing its overall impact.
This is one reason why it is important to mention psychological symptoms to both treating clinicians and the solicitor dealing with a personal injury claim.
How Is a Psychiatric Injury Claim Valued?
In Scotland, compensation for the pain and suffering caused by an injury is known as solatium.
There is no fixed compensation tariff for psychiatric injuries in Scotland.
The value will depend on factors such as:
- The particular psychiatric diagnoses
- The severity of the symptoms
- How long the symptoms have lasted
- The impact on work
- The impact on relationships and family life
- The effect on hobbies and everyday activities
- Treatment required
- The likelihood of recovery
- Whether symptoms are expected to continue in the future
Solicitors and courts can use the Judicial College Guidelines as a reference when considering an appropriate range for psychiatric injury, alongside previous court decisions involving comparable circumstances.
Any associated financial losses may also form part of the overall claim. These could include loss of earnings, treatment expenses or other losses resulting from the condition.
How Long Do Psychiatric Injury Claims Take?
There is no standard timescale.
In some cases, the longer-term impact of a psychiatric injury may not be clear immediately.
An expert may recommend treatment before a final prognosis can be given, or symptoms may need to be monitored over a period of time to establish whether they are likely to resolve.
This can make it important not to assess a psychiatric injury too early. A proper understanding of the diagnosis, treatment and likely recovery can be necessary before the full impact of the condition can be valued.
What Should I Do if an Accident Is Affecting My Mental Health?
The priority should be getting appropriate support.
If psychological symptoms develop following an accident:
- Speak to your GP or another healthcare professional
- Explain the symptoms you are experiencing
- Follow appropriate treatment or referral advice
- Keep a record of how symptoms affect everyday life and work
- If you already have a personal injury claim, tell the solicitor dealing with it about the psychological symptoms
Psychiatric injuries can be every bit as significant as physical injuries, but they are not always immediately apparent.
Understanding the diagnosis, its relationship to the accident and its longer-term impact is therefore an important part of assessing the full consequences of a personal injury.
How Jackson Boyd Can Help
Our specialist personal injury lawyers represent clients across Scotland in road traffic accident, employer liability and public liability claims. Learn more about our Personal Injury Services.